A problem of metaphors: Rethinking invasive species education
Katrina Maggiulli (2022) Teaching invasive species ethically: using comics to resist metaphors of moral wrongdoing & build literacy in environmental ethics, Environmental Education Research, 28:9, 1391-1409, https://doi.org/10.1080/13504622.2022.2085247
Summary written by Justin Dalaba, edited by Carrie Brown-Lima
How can we better structure invasive species messaging to build environmental literacy in ethical decision-making? Process-oriented storytelling may offer a more productive approach for educational programming in the United States.
Conservation is a ‘crisis discipline’ where science and education must move quickly to prevent potential delay in action and catastrophic consequences. In the field of invasive species, where there is an urgent need for public attention, oversimplified and sensationalized narratives may fail to capture the complicated reality and ethical decision-making process that go into management. This is true for the long-leaned-on, xenophobic rhetoric that has been reinforced through popular media: good-native vs. evil-invasive. Just as we need to re-evaluate invasive species management in response to ecosystem changes over time, the same is true for restructuring education tools in response to shifting value systems. In this thought-provoking article, Maggiulli makes the case for process-based learning through storytelling as a more productive educational strategy to build literacy in ethical environmental decision-making. The paper first dives into the unsettled ethics and value-laden nature of invasive species science and management. Maggiulli then examines freely available educational tools from the U.S. Department of Agriculture, Oregon Invasive Species Council, and the widely remixed ‘Wanted’ poster activity. The author argues that comics can be a productive education tool because they inspire critical thinking, engagement from underrepresented students, foster inquiry-based learning, and provide a space for multimedia representation and translation of scientific concepts. As the author puts it, this strategy “infuses environmental education with an ethically critical lens that is essential for developing environmentally conscious students.” While comics are not the only vector for re-envisioning invasive species education, they offer potential for restructuring public understanding of ethical problem solving on invasive species through invested critical thinking.
- Translation of scientific content into comics can offer a creative way of engaging with material that fosters deeper critical thinking and engagement
- When students are encouraged to question and reconsider invasive species messages, more complicated understandings of species interactions and environmental management are likely to emerge through narratives
- A ‘production-oriented model’ is an essential step toward educating students on how decision-making is an ongoing process and a group effort
- A fundamental shift in educational programs will require adequate support through workshops, colleague peer-level support, or institutional support from schools
- Outreach professionals can take a methodologically similar approach to their education programming by encouraging others to explore what it is like to be in the shoes of a conservation biologist or land manager, researching and making their own decisions, such as: What species will be featured? What are the potential management strategies? How will the problem be identified? How will human characters interact with the species?
Read more of our research summaries:
Torres et al. investigate what happens when you remove invasive plant species, and how timing of removal activities impacts plant communities.
Fusco et al. (2023) summarize what spatial invasive plant data is available in the United States and how it can be used.
Bradley et al. (2023) lay out ideas for better integration of invasive species and climate change policies and practices
New research questions our assumptions about invasive plants as the primary drivers of ecological degradation. Restoration success may be limited by interactions of different stressors.
In addition to documenting a departure from predictions in host-specificity testing, Simmons and Blossey present new evidence on the potential impacts and safety of water chestnut biological control.
This article reflects on how we can reframe our thinking and work to support equitable, inclusive, and just conservation science and practice.
This article explores a case study of biotic resistance, where over time native species may limit the invasion of other species. A native herbivore learns to consume an invasive alga in less than a decade.
How complete are current eDNA reference libraries for the Laurentian Great Lakes region? Can we confidently integrate invasive species detection with biodiversity sampling?
Invasive species vocalizations may be a significant avenue for competition among species. This thought-provoking article gives a glimpse into the potential effects of invasive species disrupting a soundscape.
Shifting temperature regimes can influence the suitability and spread of invasive insects, including spongy moth. How can secondary host plant connectivity support its expansion across the U.S.?
Can invasive worms serve as food for native species? How do they alter leaf litter microhabitat? New research offers insight into the potential effects and trophic interactions of jumping worms (Amynthas spp.) and native reptiles and amphibians.