Firewood Transport as a Vector of Forest Pest Dispersal in North America: A Scoping Review
Open Access: Angelica Solano, Shari L Rodriguez, Leigh Greenwood, Kevin J Dodds, David R Coyle, Firewood Transport as a Vector of Forest Pest Dispersal in North America: A Scoping Review, Journal of Economic Entomology, Volume 114, Issue 1, February 2021, Pages 14–23, https://doi.org/10.1093/jee/toaa278
A cozy campfire for summer days, a warm fireplace for winter evenings– the use of firewood is an “established cultural norm”. However, moving firewood from place to place can have devastating consequences, as it can spread forest pests that decimate forests to collectively cost an estimated $4.2 – $14.4 billion per year. In order to better address the problem of people moving firewood and vectoring forest pests, Solano and colleagues examined trends and gaps in the existing literature on firewood and human-mediated forest pest movement in North America. Using key search criteria, the team conducted a scoping review; combing through five online databases to find 24 articles on the subject, then organizing the findings of each paper into 5 themes (see summarized below). The existing literature demonstrates the risk of firewood movement, but fails to address the level of awareness the public has on such risks, or the level of effectiveness of firewood regulations to prevent forest pest spread.
Key take-aways by theme:
- Insect incidence in firewood: Insects can persist for years in firewood; the risk of spreading forest pests is still high long after wood has been split or treated.
- Insect dispersal via firewood: While invasive forest pests (like emerald ash borer, EAB) may initially be introduced by overseas transport, the insects can quickly and broadly disperse through the new region through firewood movement.
- Recreational firewood movement: When it comes to western State or National Parks, 32% of campers bring firewood from out-of-state, traveling an average of 147 miles for their trip– carrying major potential for spreading forest pests.
- Efficacy of firewood treatments: While heat-treating wood (60˚C internally for 60 minutes) was demonstrated to eliminate EAB in one study, another study found using similar temperature standards (56˚C) was not effective at eliminating all EAB. Other studies showed that a combination of debarking and heating-treating firewood logs can eliminate insects like the walnut twig beetle.
- Behavior and rule compliance of firewood users: In one study, the most common reasons campers cited for transporting firewood had to do with cost, convenience and quality. Additionally, demonstrating the negative impacts of invasive forest insects, and decreasing the cost of local firewood may be effective for triggering behavioral change.
- Encourage the public to not move firewood by consistently demonstrating firewood’s role in the negative consequences of invasive forest insects. Motivate compliance by ensuring an agreeable price, convenience, and quality of local firewood.
- Assess the effectiveness of any outreach efforts by using a metric to assess the public’s change in behavior.
- Additional resources can be found at https://www.dontmovefirewood.org/.
Read more of our research summaries:
Functional eradication, a new framework for invasive species control, focuses on suppressing invasive species below levels that have significant negative impacts on conservation targets.
Invasive forest pests can spread when people move firewood from place to place, but this review helps to identify how we can prevent it from spreading further.
Advances in eDNA research show promise for estimating the abundance of invasive fish populations using water samples.
Garlic mustard may occupy forest understories, but mounting evidence shows that with time, populations of this ubiquitous invader are in decline.
Plant competition seemingly plays out before our eyes, but Zhang et al. find that invasive plants may gain a competitive edge through unseen soil interactions.
Buying aquarium organisms from across the world can be as easy as the click of a button, and that's the problem.
If you’re an invasive shrub, you hold on to your leaves– citizen scientists helped to find that extended leaf phenology between native and invasive shrubs gets more similar as you move northward.
How do some aquatic species with low-mobility become widespread? Dispersing locally gives an advantage, and playing stowaway gets them the rest of the way.
Perennial Pepperweed, a widespread invasive in the west and emerging invader in the northeast, can be managed by restoring hydrologic regimes- herbicides can help too.
When managing for forest regeneration, deer may be a more important stressor to address than invasive grasses.
Success: a fungus can help suppress Spotted Lanternfly, invasive insect to the Northeast U.S.
Studying silvicultural techniques to promote the longevity of hemlock trees faced with hemlock woolly adelgid